Charles's been a plumber his entire life. Thanks to his vast experience we can always rely on Charles' expert opinion when creating any of our articles. He's also a fantasti read more
Last updated: March 12, 2023
Bathroomer is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here
Are you in desperate need of a new toilet? Well, the good news is that you don’t have to break the bank to get one. There are many affordable options under $200 on the market, but finding the right one may be more complicated than you think. That’s why we’ve created our list of the top-rated picks that should help you with your final choice.
What makes the best toilet under $200? Here, we’ll explore the most important criteria that might affect your decision. First, the type is crucial as you can either get a one or two-piece. You’ll also want to pay attention to the shape to ensure that the particular model suits you. Don’t forget to check how much water it uses in the flush system for the economy and other key specifications, such as material, dimensions, and warranty. With that being said, the TOTO CST244EF#12 Entrada Toilet gets the Editor’s Choice nomination. Are you ready to learn more? Let’s get started!
More features: universal height, ADA, WaterSense, CALGreen, and CEC compliant
We think this is the best toilet under $200 due to several different reasons. It’s a two-piece toilet that is going to perfectly fit into most bathrooms, and its bowl is also elongated for anyone who prefers that shape.
The flush system uses 1.28 GPF and utilizes the water very well for a high level of efficiency. It’s made from porcelain, and you can tell that the build quality is excellent. On top of that, it has a universal height to suit almost everyone, and all of this is backed by a solid 1-year warranty.
Why did it make our list? With the exceptional build quality and low price, this gives you brilliant value for money. What we also love is that it’s able to flush with a big level of power, is relatively quiet, and doesn’t use up much water.
What is not ideal about it? Despite being pictured with one, this toilet doesn’t come with a seat. That can be quite common when buying toilets, so it’s something to look out for when looking at others.
Warranty: 5-year against staining or fading of porcelain glaze, 3-year on flushing mechanism and seat lid
More features: compact size, 16.5″ seat length, self-cleaning glazed surface, comes with soft-closing seat and wax ring
If you want to get a one-piece toilet under $200, then this is going to be perfect. The build quality is very high here, which is shown by offering an extended warranty on the porcelain material used.
One of the most significant features here is the dual-flush system that will give you either 1.1 or 1.6 GPF depending on what button you press. It has an elongated shape and is relatively compact when compared with other models.
What are its best features? This toilet comes with a soft-closing lid, which works very well. The compact design gives you versatility in installation, and the whole process will be relatively easy. Also, the maintenance is effortless, which provides this toilet with excellent usability.
What could be improved? While the soft-close system works well, the lid that comes with the toilet doesn’t give you the highest level of quality. Most people would be happy with it, but the long-term durability is questionable.
Warranty: lifetime on chinaware and 5-year on mechanical parts
More features: PowerWash rim, WaterSense certified, antimicrobial surface, fully glazed 2″ trap-way, 9″ x 8″ surface area, chrome finish trip lever
This toilet is unique in that it is covered in vitreous china, which can make the material tougher and shinier than toilets that are made of ceramic or porcelain without coating. It helps to give it excellent durability, which is shown by the lifetime warranty on the chinaware.
There are many great features here, such as the economical 1.1 GPF, a PowerWash rim, and also a microbial surface. It’s a two-piece toilet and has a round shape, which might be appealing for those who prefer it. Thus, it’s a brilliant toilet that could be the perfect choice for you.
What are our favorite features? This toilet gets a lot of power from just 1.1 GPF of water. That prevents any blockages while also cutting down on your water bills. Additionally, it’s reasonably quiet, which is ideal if it’s situated next to a bedroom.
What could be better? This is another toilet that is known to have some cracking issues. This isn’t going to happen when in use but can occur in delivery. Therefore, just check its quality as soon as you can.
More features: compact design, self-cleaning glazed surface, quiet and powerful flushing, pre-installed soft closing seat, includes high-quality wax ring, floor bolts
DeerValley is another company that has made an elegant one-piece toilet that is going to look great in any bathroom. It’s made from ceramic and has a high level of sturdiness, which means it should last for years.
It’s an exceptionally compact toilet that doesn’t use much water at all, with less than a gallon for a quick flush. A great feature here is that it comes with a pre-installed self-closing seat, which not only works well but saves you from needing to buy a new one.
What makes it stand out? Just because it’s a toilet, it doesn’t mean that it can’t be stylish, and we think that this model looks great. Apart from that, the efficiency of it is very impressive, and the whole build quality is great. It’s reasonably compact without being too small, and that gives it a versatile design.
Which disadvantages must you keep in mind? The flush button does feel a little flimsy when you push it down. This isn’t a big issue, but we do prefer to have more of a weighted feel.
Flush system: pedal (half-way to add water, full activation for flush)
Dimensions: 15.75” x 18.25” x 19”
More features: textured lid, high profile, easy to install and service
If you are looking for a reliable RV toilet, then this would be perfect. It has that compact size that saves a lot of space while still having a comfortable elongated shape. Thus, it finds the ideal balance between comfort and size.
The pedal flush activation makes it very easy to use and actually has dual-use. The product is made from plastic, which is typical for an RV toilet. On top of those features, the toilet is also simple to install and only requires minimal maintenance.
What are its best features? We enjoyed the flush action on this, and it’s an area where many RV toilets can suffer. It also has a sturdy design, and you’ll have no issues with using it. Overall, it works very well and quickly clears away any contents.
What could be improved? As we’ve already mentioned, it has fully plastic construction, which can make it feel a little cheap. The plastic used here, however, appears to be quite durable, so it should stand the test of time.
Here, we see another RV toilet, but this one has a round bowl. Whether you prefer a round or elongated shape, this is mostly going to come down to personal preference. At only one pint per flush, this toilet has very impressive efficiency.
Despite its smaller body, it still has a full-sized seat, so you get the best of both worlds. Installation is quite simple, and it’s made from highly durable polypropylene plastic. The flush system is also very easy to use and works well in any RV.
What do we love it for? There is a lot to love about this toilet. First, the design gives you incredible efficiency while also allowing for versatile installation. Next, the durability is also impressive, considering it’s an RV toilet, so setting it up shouldn’t be an issue.
What were we disappointed with? We did notice that this toilet was somewhat top-heavy, so it can lack a little stability. If you secure it correctly with the two bolts, this shouldn’t be too much of an issue.
More features: 2” flush valve and 2” trap-way, generous 9″ x 8″ water surface area
This is the best toilet under $200 for anyone looking for a 1.6 GPF system. It has incredible power, and you’ll never need to worry about it clogging. Also, it’s another option that comes in two pieces and has an elongated shape.
This is one of the largest toilets we looked at, so it’s going to be ideal for most big bathrooms. Additionally, it comes with a 2-year warranty, which demonstrates the high level of build quality it has. It’s made from porcelain and can improve the aesthetics of any bathroom.
What makes it special? This toilet was very easy to install, even for those that aren’t experts. There are also plenty of buying options in terms of both colors and size, and all of them are affordable. Thus, it’s a fantastic toilet and one that works very quickly to empty and contents of the bowl.
What cons did we find? Some users have noted a few issues in terms of getting bowls that are cracked. It seems like a rare complaint, but we’d recommend inspecting the toilet as soon as you get it, just in case.
Things to Consider
When looking at a toilet under $200, it’s easy to get one that simply isn’t at the right level of quality. That makes it especially important to find one that is of great value for money and has positive reviews. That’s why we wanted to create this buying guide so you can get the perfect solution for you. To do that, we’ve gone through all of the critical features while answering some essential FAQs. Hopefully, you can then develop a clear idea of the perfect toilet.
Are toilets under $200 any good?
There are many great toilets to be found under $200. At that level, you can still expect a high build quality with great styling. The toilets that are much more expensive than $200 don’t tend to have a higher build quality but instead will have a different set of features.
A model such as the TOTO CST244EF#12 Entrada can’t be faulted. It has a high level of build quality and is able to flush powerfully while using up a minimal amount of water. These are common traits through all of the toilets we’ve looked at here.
On premium toilets, you’ll see features such as an integrated bidet or even electronic control, which aren’t really required. Some of them have very powerful suction but offer 360-degree flushing and high efficiency. What we’ve seen here is that toilets under $200 are able to compete with those features very well.
How to pick the best toilet under $200
Every bathroom is different, and what you determine as the best toilet may be different to someone else. It’s essential to ask the right questions. How big should your toilet be? How much water should it use? Do you want a dual-flush? As we go through this buying guide, it’s good to make a mental note of each of the features as you’ll then build up a picture of exactly what you need.
You’ll have the choice between a one or two-piece toilet. A two-piece toilet, such as the TOTO CST244EF#12 Entrada, is famous for many reasons as they are generally cheaper and also a lot lighter. Also, you can get plenty of options in terms of height and style.
As for the one-piece models, the DeerValley DV-1F52812 is seen as a great option as it is easier to clean and install. They are, however, usually more expensive and heavier. In terms of flushing performance, there is no difference between them.
You also have RV toilets, which are as small and made of plastic. These have less performance but are perfect for those more compact environments.
There are generally two shapes of toilets as you have either the round as shown on the American Standard 288DA Toilet or the elongated shape. This usually just comes down to personal preference, but there are some factors to note.
A round toilet is more compact and therefore ideal for smaller spaces. Also, it’s more traditional in its style. Elongated options feature a modern design, which many people find more comfortable. Find the one which is easier for you to use.
Not all toilets are the same size, and, in many bathrooms, the space that you have can be limited. It’s important to get a toilet that allows for enough room around it. A compact toilet such as the DeerValley DV-1F52812 can be ideal for those tighter spots.
The American Standard 221CA Toilet is an example of one that is a little bigger. It’s also good to consider the footprint of your toilet. If you had tiling, for instance, around the base of your old model, then you’ll probably want to find a replacement that slots into that space.
You’ll see “GPF” used to describe toilets, and that stands for Gallons Per Flush. Old style toilets were extremely inefficient and could use up to 7 gallons of water for one flush. Thankfully, toilets these days are a lot better, such as the American Standard 288DA that only needs 1.1 gallons.
For some users, 1.1 GPF doesn’t give you enough force, and it can mean you need to clean your toilet more often. If you want something a little bigger, the 1.6 GPF could be what you need. A dual-flush can also be a great feature as this gives you the option of having a small flush when needed.
You’ll see that toilets are almost always made from either or porcelain, but which one is better? Well, technically, it’s porcelain as it’s more durable.
The two materials, however, are very similar, so it’s not a big deal which one you get. There is also vitreous china coating, as shown on the American Standard 288DA. Thanks to this finish, the toilet is even more durable and easier to clean. There is also plastic, but this is only really seen on RV toilets such as the Aqua-Magic V model.
When buying a new toilet online, the pictures on the webpages can be a little misleading at times. In all of the photos that you look at, they’ll be shown with having a seat. In reality, many are sold without one, and you’ll just get the bowl instead. This can be very frustrating for those who didn’t read the small print.
Due to this, it’s always a good idea to double-check exactly what you’ll be getting. The DeerValley DV-1F52812 Compact Toilet is an example of a model that comes with a high-quality seat. This is comfortable and means you don’t need to shop around for one.
Ease of installation
As mentioned in the seat section, you don’t always get everything you need when installing a toilet. You’ll most likely need wax rings and bolts to complete the installation. Sometimes you can get these from your old toilet, but they’re not always compatible.
You also want to check the rough-in, which is the measurement from the wall to the center of the drain, which is usually 12”. In terms of installation, one-piece toilets are usually the easiest, but they are heavier. The American Standard 288DA is an example of a two-piece toilet that is still easy to install.
It’s always a good idea to get a long warranty should anything go wrong with your toilet. The Dometic 300 Series Standard Height Toilet has a great 2-year warranty that should give you plenty of confidence in its build quality and durability.
Once installed, these toilets tend to have excellent durability, but there can be issues in delivery. It’s important to inspect your toilet as soon as you get it. If there are any cracks or defects, you should alert the company as soon as you can.
Firstly, you need to remove the old toilet. This involves turning off the water, draining the toilet, and then disconnecting the water supply. Once you’ve done that, you can then remove the toilet cistern, unscrew the mounting nuts and pull up the toilet. You can then remove the old wax ring and flange.
Installing a new toilet is pretty much those steps in reverse. You’ll start by installing the new mounting bolts and wax ring. Once you’ve done that, you can fit the toilet and tighten the nuts. Add the cistern if you have a two-piece toilet. After you’ve connected the water supply, you should check carefully to see if there are any leaks.
Maintaining a toilet is fairly easy as most people will reach for a brush and use bleach. This is a great combination most of the time, but there are other occasions where it may need a deeper clean. If you notice the rust rings, then there are a few tricks that work, such as using cola or white vinegar, which helps to dissolve it. Another way to keep your toilet looking new is to scrub it with a pumice stone. If your toilet becomes clogged, it’s a good idea to see if using boiling water works first before you turn to expensive chemicals.
Ceramic and porcelain are commonly used with toilets as they provide a surface that is very hard to stain while also having enough weight to provide enough stability. They are also highly durable, which is why the material is used for expensive toilets, as well as those under $200.
All of the toilets that we’ve looked at here have impressive durability and should last for a vast number of years. It’s not something that you’ll need to worry about. If you are concerned about durability, look for a toilet that has a strong warranty that will give you the confidence you need.
We looked at many great toilets here. Perhaps the one that impressed us the most was the TOTO CST244EF#12 Entrada. It has excellent flushing efficiency while having enough power to ensure you have a clog-free toilet.
While these three were great, all the models here have an impressive mix of qualities. It’s important to choose the best toilet under $200 that you love and most closely matches what you need. Once you’ve made your choice, you’ll love the design and efficiency of your new toilet.